|
Post by captainnemo on Jul 11, 2012 10:20:09 GMT -5
(1995) Garbage - Take out "As Heaven Is Wide" and replace it with "Trip My Wire" (1998) Version 2.0 - Take out "Medication" and replace it with "Thirteen" (2001) Beautiful Garbage - Take out "Can't Cry These Tears" and replace it with "Use Me" (2005) Bleed Like Me - Take out "Bleed Like Me" and replace it with "Never Be Free" (2012) Not Your Kind Of People - Obviously No b-sides yet, but once there is a great one, I'd remove "Felt" and replace it with that b-side.
|
|
|
Post by Hangin' With The Bichard on Jul 11, 2012 12:40:47 GMT -5
You'd remove As Heaven Is Wide? Insanity?!
I'm not sure I can do this, as on some of the later albums there are too many great b-sides that should have been on the albums and I can't restrict myself to choosing just one replacement!
|
|
|
Post by mc6623 on Jul 11, 2012 13:22:40 GMT -5
Garbage - replace Dog New Tricks with #1 Crush Version 2.0 - replace When I Grow Up with Lick the Pavement Beautifulgarbage - replace Parade with Use Me Bleed Like Me - replace Sex is not the Enemy with Never Be Free NYKOP - replace Big Bright World with The One (if that counts)
|
|
|
Post by Clay on Jul 11, 2012 13:33:47 GMT -5
The One counts. And yes, there are 6 NYKOP era b-sides
|
|
|
Post by Hangin' With The Bichard on Jul 11, 2012 13:50:25 GMT -5
6? I only count 5! Have I missed something?!
Right I'll give this a go:
Garbage: Replace Dog New Tricks with Subhuman (although I'd quite like to ditch A Stroke of Luck for Trip My Wire as well)
Version 2.0: Replace Medication with 13XForever (I prefer Get Busy With The Fizzy but it would stick out like a sore thumb!)
Beautifulgarbage: Replace Can't Cry These Tears with Enough Is Never Enough (although the amazing Sex Never Goes Out Of Fashion, Begging Bone, Confidence and Use Me are all better than about half the album...this era had the best b-sides IMO).
Bleed Like Me: Replace Right Between The Eyes with Never Be Free (I'd quite happily cut Bad Boyfriend and Happy Home for Space Can Come Through Anyone and Nobody Can Win too as it goes).
Not Your Kind Of People: Replace Beloved Freak with Show Me (this was probably the easiest actually...I'd like to get rid of Man On A Wire in favour of The One as well...)
|
|
|
Post by garbagefiend on Jul 11, 2012 18:19:39 GMT -5
Beautifulgarbage: Replace Can't Cry These Tears with Enough Is Never Enough (although the amazing Sex Never Goes Out Of Fashion, Begging Bone, Confidence and Use Me are all better than about half the album...this era had the best b-sides IMO) Totally agree! G - #1 Crush in place of Fix Me Now V2.0 - Deadwood instead of Medication and 13x Forever instead of Wicked Ways (still perfection anyways) BG - Use Me instead of Can't Cry, Begging Bone instead of Til the Day I Die and Never Enough for...Untouchable (I actually like Can't Cry by the way, but I don't know..it's just too loud/60's and doesn't fit in haha) BLM - Never Be Free instead of WDYCO NYKOP - The One instead of NYKOP
|
|
|
Post by calichaos on Jul 11, 2012 22:40:04 GMT -5
(1995) Garbage - Take out "A Stroke Of Luck" and replace it with "#1 Crush" (1998) Version 2.0 - Take out "Wicked Ways" and replace it with "Soldier Through this" (2001) Beautiful Garbage - Take out "Til the Day I Die" and replace it with "Use Me" (2005) Bleed Like Me - Take out "WDYCO" and replace it with "Never Be Free" (2012) Not Your Kind Of People - Take Out "Man On A Wire" replace it with "Bright Tonight" On the standard edition
IMHO k thanks bai!
|
|
|
Post by Garbage Addict on Jul 12, 2012 3:14:18 GMT -5
Garbage - wouldn't really change the debut as its flawless, but possibly A Stroke of Luck for Subhuman simply as I prefer the later and it would have sat nicely with Vow
Version 2.0 - Wicked Ways for Deadwood or Soldier Through This (though that be 2 ballads in a row. It's a pacing thing )
BG - only song I'd ever change be Untouchable as its my least fav. Untouchable for Use Me
BLM - the dire WDYCO for Never Be Free or Nobody Can Win (if they reworked it perhaps )
NYKOP - wouldn't change a thing it flows very well. I prefer The One in their somewhere maybe as a twelfth song but not sure where I'd put it so.
|
|
|
Post by vickii on Jul 12, 2012 17:58:03 GMT -5
I wouldn't change anything about the first two albums. They were perfect albums with, in my opinion, essentially perfect B-Sides. As for BeautifulGarbage and Bleed Like Me, well, to be honest I actually significantly prefer most of the B-Sides from those two albums to the actual tracks on both of them, and I don't necessarily dislike those albums at all, I just adore the B-Sides from them, including "Betcha" from the "Tell Me Where it Hurts" single. Like the first two albums I think I would as well keep Not Your Kind Of People the way it is and maybe just extend the album itself by adding the bones tracks to the original edition.
|
|
|
Post by andrei on Jul 12, 2012 19:58:28 GMT -5
I wouldn't change anything about the first two albums. They were perfect albums I agree. perfect albums indeed. B-sides great too but not "perfect" like the album songs. But the rest? bg - Untouchable off / Enough is never enough on blm - blm off / Space can come through anyone on (so groovy!) nykop - umm, I prefer all albums songs to all bonus songs, so I leave that alone like the first 2.
|
|
|
Post by umbrto on Jul 13, 2012 11:30:50 GMT -5
Debut: Not my idea / sleep --------> This is the only album I wouldn't change anything. And for me, Sleep is not only a song. Is THE SONG.
Version 2.0: Sleep together / thirteen ---> What a lovely ballad is this and never liked the first one.
Beautiful Garbage: Untouchable / begging bone ---> But the second bersiĆ³n of the b-side. The one that the band uploaded on facebook a few months ago.
Bleed like me: Why don't you come over ---> Honey Bee. The second is quite better.
Not your kind of people: I agree with some of you. None of the extra tracks are as goog as any of the albums tracks. I wouldn't replace any of it.
|
|
|
Post by ~*Bitter Lily*~ on Jul 14, 2012 13:19:44 GMT -5
This is really difficult, but I guess if I was held at gunpoint, I would change them as follows: Garbage: As Heaven Is Wide---->#1 Crush Version 2.0: When I Grow Up---->13 X Forever Beautiful Garbage: Androgyny & Untouchable---->Enough Is Never Enough & Sex Never Goes Out Of Fashion (This album was easy!) Bleed Like Me: Happy Home---->Never Be Free Not Your Kind Of People Standard: Felt---->The One Not Your Kind Of People Deluxe: Felt---->Love Like Suicide
|
|
|
Post by ifyoucaretolisten on Jul 14, 2012 15:08:24 GMT -5
Garbage - I wouldn't change the debut at ALL.. but, My Lover's Box for Trip My Wire (painful decision!) Version 2.0 - Sleep Together for Deadwood beautifulgarbage - Untouchable for Begging Bone Bleed Like Me - Why Don't You Come Over or Why Do You Love Me for Honeybee NYKOP - I Hate Love for What Girls Are Made Of
|
|
|
Post by aztalanturf on Jul 14, 2012 15:14:11 GMT -5
- Garbage: Dog New Tricks >> #1 Crush (original version, not R & J version); Trip My Wire wouldn't fit as well in that slot, but I do love it so.
- Version 2.0: Wouldn't change anything. My favorite b-side from this era is Deadwood, but it just doesn't fit anywhere.
- beautifulgarbage: Til the Day That I Die >> Begging Bone
- Bleed Like Me: WDYCO >> Space Can Come Through Anyone
- NYKOP: BBW >> What Girls Are Made Of. I would really like to fit in The One, but I think it'd be way too much of a 1-2 punch after ASH. Both are very in your face. The rockiness of WGAMO would flow well into BFP. I think that's why they chose BBW as second...it takes a little while to get going which gives you a short breather after ASH.
|
|